In the same price range no brand has a real advantage over the other. The most important thing is fit, followed by components. Since you've ruled out the 1.1, concentrate on the fit (although the 1.1 may have been poorly adjusted-- if you like it otherwise, tell the store & see if they can adjust it to address your concerns). If you can find someone more knowledgeable about bikes try to let them see the bikes & get their opinion. Otherwise, try to read up here on components till you are comfortable knowing the differences-- there are many threads on this. Then try to test ride as much as possible & go with your gut.

Another factor, altho less significant, is how you feel about the shops. A good shop will help you with adjustments, offer discounts on accessories, etc. after you buy a bike there. A bad shop will treat you like an annoyance.

The above being said, I'm not familiar with the bikes in question.