View Single Post
Old 05-19-10 | 09:48 AM
  #43  
PaulRivers
Senior Member
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 6,431
Likes: 44
From: Minneapolis, MN
Originally Posted by pkazmierczak
yeah well, I'm riding mainly on the road, but I don't think slick tires would be a good choice in Bergen. every now and then I have to take a gravel path and then having these knobs really pays off. It's just that I haven't ridden an MTB for a long long time, and I'm not used to such tires
How would you describe these gravel paths? Are they bike paths? Beaten down walking paths?

There's an understandable (though untrue) theme that people have that a skinny road tire can only be ridden on pure pavement. With people new to biking who are buying their first bike, I've heard "I might ride across grass sometime so I need a mountain bike with suspension and knobby tires" a lot - though it's totally untrue.

I regularly ride my 23c tire road race bike (Specialized Tarmac) on a crushed limestone MUP by where I live. And across grass whenever need be. Without *any* drawbacks (well - the vibration absorbing frame definitely helps with comfort on the trail :-)).

Here's pictures of someone else doing the same thing:




A gravel bike path isn't a problem for a skinny road tire. The limits for a skinny road tire, from my experience, are -
1. An actual dirt road designed for cars - with much larger rocks I can ride it, but it's bumpy and unpleasant. A fatter road slick would handle this fine I would expect, though.
2. Gravel when it's wet. The skinnier tire sinks into it more and has trouble getting a grip. A wider tire would be better. I'm not sure if knobbies would help, they probably would.
3. Loose gravel - paths that aren't packed down. Here knobbies are definitely a necessity.

But riding over stretches of grass, gravel bike trails, or even just packed down trails through the woods when it's not wet - a wider slick tire is almost overkill and works great.

And a skinny road tire is definitely better on the road. Full knobbies are worse in every aspect on the road - they brake worse (less contact with the road and the knobs flex when braking), they turn worse (doing a high speed turn works on a slick, on a knobby you'll fall over), they're slower, noisier, etc. Sounds like you're running a cyclocross tire so it's not as bad, just saying - it's counter intuitive, but if you've tried it that's how it goes, tread isn't helpful at all on the road.

Anyways, I probably wrote way to much, lol. Have fun. :-)

Last edited by PaulRivers; 05-19-10 at 09:51 AM.
PaulRivers is offline  
Reply