If you are choosing between the Trek FX or Valencia. You should try the riding position which is more comfortable. The FX is a little bit more aggressive. If they both are the same I would go with the Valencia. I commute 14 mile each way in New York City in all weather. The Bonteger hard case I found slippery in wet weather and replaced them with Bonteger All Weather hard case. Full fenders will keep your bike clean in wet weather.