depends on what you mean by "durable."
in terms of skidding, then the differences should be negligible.
in terms of maintenence, you may find 28's a bit more forgiving in the pinch flat department. but if you always keep your tires up to proper pressure, you'll be just fine.
oh, and keep in mind that tire clearance might also be an issue. make sure your tires will fit your frame. i don't own a madison, but i'm sure scrod will pop up shortly to set you in the right direction.
if you're really hard-set on a durable tire, i suggest you consider other tires. one of the many other tire threads will give you an idea about what people prefer for ride-quality, durability, and rolling resistance.