Originally Posted by jfmckenna
Why do people cut these saddles?
Does it make it more comfortable or something?
It doesn't alter comfort, but IMO fixes and tracks look better without all that extra touring bike-y leather. Of course, you could go out and buy a Swift or a Swallow, but you can get the same vintage (...yes, vintage. Trimming a B17 or Pro is nothing new, and even if it were, Swifts and Swallows have been around for quite a while) look for a fraction of the cost. And seeing the rails gives the impression of a slightly longer post/higher saddle, as well- another benefit. I use a regular B17 on my geared "everything" bike, but a nice track frame deserves a thinner saddle. You do want to consider weight (yours, not the bike's) and possibly thigh size if you decide to do this- just make sure not to cut off too much. It's also better, IMO, to do this to a new saddle than a broken-in one. I wouldn't mess with one I liked.