View Single Post
Old 09-09-10 | 11:07 AM
  #49  
kreative
Senior Member
 
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 121
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by cab chaser
Care to back that claim up with some evidence?

Advantages of a singlespeed drivetrain over gears:

- No derailleurs to maintain.
- Less weight thanks to no detailers, a single chainring and no cassette.
- A more durable bike.
- A simplified drive train without the additional resistance provided by the upper/lower jockey wheels required by a derailleur system.
- No need for asymmetrical wheel dishing to accommodate a cassette, resulting in more durable wheelsets.
- Can still coast.

Advantages of a singlespeed drivetrain over fixed:

- I can coast down hills as fast as I want.
- I can keep an absolutely silent core while braking hard and shifting my weight back as far as possible (since I can stop my feet while maintaining rear traction at high speed).
- All of my energy goes to moving the the bike forward and none of my bicycle's (forward or wheelspin) momentum ever gets wasted on lifting up my feet.
- I can spin rpms well into the red zone of my body's capabilities, without worrying about having to keep up with the pedals or being knocked off balance by them if I lose steam.
- I am generally more nimble thanks to my ability to stop and start my cranks at any moment I want, in any position I want.

Yeah. Singlespeeds suck. Whatever am I thinking "cruising around" NYC traffic on my singlespeed drive train.

As far as the dead-zone goes: you are still translating your bike's momentum into pedal momentum, which is energy going the wrong way. It is no harder to continue cycling in the dead zone on a singlespeed, you're just much less likely to lose any energy to bad cycling technique when you are tired. If the dead zone is a problem for you on climbs, you are not strong enough for the gain in your drivetrain given the terrain you are riding on.
Advantages of a geared bike over SS:
- highest efficiency through gearing for climbing, sprinting, speed
- higher speeds since you don't spin out as readily
- weight is usually a wash since road frames are mostly carbon fiber whereas most SS are aluminum or steel
- can still coast

Advantages of a Fixed over SS:
- can pedal down hills as fast as you want (or can), which will help increase the suppleness of your legs. (disclaimer: not saying it's easy....)
- can brake with a combination of hand brakes and legs, useful if your brakes fail, or your hands slip, or can't grab them in time
- no coasting, which means no wasted energy or momentum while going forward
- no coasting, which will break bad habits of coasting too much
- no coasting, which generally means being more mindful, and more awareness of your riding ability, and technique
- no coasting, which generally means more awareness of your environment and surroundings (eg. traffic, stop signs, etc.)
- the ability to skid
- the ability to ride backwards (hmmm...is this an advantage? lol)
- more challenging

Last edited by kreative; 09-09-10 at 11:10 AM.
kreative is offline  
Reply