I would not buy a Brooks both because it is leather, but also because I need a hornless seat. I have a Spongy Wonder on order and I hold out high hopes for it, I can't wait to try it out. I am 21 and I already have ED and sexual anhedonia, and I really think cycling has been a contributor. Would a Brooks have prevented it? Possibly, but really its the same design as other conventional saddles, and still puts pressure on the perineum.
Textile toe straps are as available as leather ones by now, too.