I have kind of mixed opinions on this. I think the Gator Hardshell might be more tire than I want. I have to wonder how much of the lively ride I like on my Ultra Gatorskins would be negated by a stiffer sidewall and heavier tire overall that the Hardshell seems to offer.
I would kind of like to see an Ultra Gatorskin in 700X32, but am pretty satisfied with the 700x28. I personally think the addition of a 700X32mm Ultra Gatorskin would have been better news than the addition of the Hardcase, but I am fairly tolerant of fixing a flat once in a while and highly value a lively feeling ride. Still it is nice to see an expansion of the line.