Personally, when my extremeties are warm, my core is warm too. So I have booties, good pair of gloves, and a beanie.
Every persons physiology is different but you should have some idea of how you react to extreme temperatures.

Use your experiences from camping/hiking/football, outdoor activities/sports that you may have done in the past.

Think about that before you invest heavily in more expensive items, such as thermal bibs (which you may not need).