FWIW the 90$ one is made of oiled cotton...the cheaper ones are some kind of vinyl/plastic i'm sure.

I'm not 100% sold on the idea, but from the discussions i've read it seems like a good choice for me. My other option would be a jacket and pants i suppose.

I don't particularly like biking in jackets though. When its warm out I just get wet.

If the campmor one is long enough I think it looks good. The Cyclechic one looks plenty long ...they say its unisex (i could care less) but i suppose the model could be a very small person.