I'm in NYC which is usually warmer than Cleveland (Go Jets).
But Wool is my go to winter gear except when the temps start at 10-20 degrees, then maybe a wool base layer.

It is Important to know that wool can be different as night and day so understand a few things:
a) Thickness of stiching
b) Weight of Thread
c) Quality of manufacturer

A tighter sttich/weave will block wind and keep you warmer
A heavier thread will do the same and keep you toasty warm like a HEAVY sweater should
The wool should NOT be too baggy or loose on you.

Check IBEX and they can explain what the difference is from a 150 to a 325 weight sweater or jacket.
I wear 230 weight base layer with a shortsleeve 300 weight jersey for 37-50 degrres. If its's windy I use a Standard vest with a mesh back. I commute 23 miles EACH way and it does the job. It has been really
windy lately so at times it's a bit challenging. If I wear a wind breaker I tend to get too sweaty which is always an issue with me.

Good Luck