Went to the LBS and measured my sit bones again. 120mm.
Also today put on a velo orange 90mm stem 17 degree (old stem was 100mm 17 degree), and nitto b-115 drop bars. Have them stem flipped so it gives the bar rise. I think it ended up lowering them a tad, but put them closer to me and can definitely feel it. Kinda crazy how much 1cm makes. The bike fits me a lot better now.
So, decided to give the team pro another shot. I think I had it tilted up a tad last time, now it's level, or maybe 1 or 2 degrees pointed downward. Much better. Also got a new seat post so in the process of swapping, my saddle is about .5 cm higher now too.
Just going to keep it and give it some more time. Really like how it looks (team pro classic black), and once it forms to be a bit I think the thicker leather might actually be a plus. I guess I'll see.