I recommend layers. I use Pearl Izumi ShoftShells (full fingers with grippy spots on thumb and index finger for shifting) on cool but not frigid days, then add liners on frigid days (Icebreaker makes some great merino wool liners). That said, the combination will run you 70 bucks or so. You could be just as comfortable with any decent thickness glove that has Thinsulate, or Thinsulate plus Windblock material on the outside.