What I wear for weather right above freezing: winter gloves + winter hat, thin sweater + jacket. Basically the sweater is warm enough and the jacket is just for some "wind-proof-ness", so it's easy to use a light-weight jacket that looks decent. If I need something really waterproof because of real rain I wear rain paints + rain jacket + rain boots and I have to accept the fact that I will look like I just crawled out of a manhole.