I have a Giant Tran Sport LX for commuting and a Specialized Myka for off-road. My husband rides a Specialized Hardrock for everything. I only rode about 3000 miles this year (lost my mojo for a bit and when I got it back I came down with mono) my husband more than 5000. We enjoy our bikes, my husband is pleased with the quality of his bike, and he is pretty rough on his. As has been said, the 2 most important things are finding a good local bike shop, and getting a bike that fits. Riding the Erie Canal towpath is one of my Bucket List rides. Find a good shop, find a bike that fits and ride!!!