Took it to the LBS and had a mechanic look at it. He said he hadn't seen anything like it before but for sure it wasn't working properly. Asked how old the bike was (about 6 mo) and said he assumed it would be covered under warrenty but that his manager would have to look at it and he wouldn't be in until Tuesday. So the bike is going back down on Tues. (I asked my wife if she wanted it like it was for the weekend and she did) and hopefully I get a new shifter from Shimano...if not I guess I will be upgrading it to 9 speed as I will have to buy a new pair and 9 spd is all I could find on the net.
Thanks to those that had helpful responses.
__________________
The views expressed by this poster do not reflect the views of BikeForums.net.