Originally Posted by
HillRider
I don't know what the OP's crank configuration is but big-big+1" is never a mistake unless you change the cassette for a larger one without adjusting it.
I agree.
I'm assuming that the OP has the 53, 42, 30t OE crankset and a 12-25 cassette as stated. Installing a 26t granny gear will require a chain wrap range of 40, the 39t chainwrap range of the Shimano GS RD has a safety factor. He is right at the upper range of the RD chain wrap capacity.
I first assumed that he had a 50t big chainring, so my first calculation is off. However he should still shorten the chain using the Big-Big +1 as you suggested. I would be suprised if he had slack on the small-small combo after resizing.
Michael