The fenders were great.

Only light sprinkles on the ride in. We went out for lunch and I was a little worried about getting soaked, fenders or not. But the rain held off until we got back to work.
The ride home was a little wetter. Half way home I removed my rain jacket. I was getting wetter from sweat than rain.
I like the fenders. No spray from the tires to get my legs and shoes wet.