I also vote for the Bluemels. Coincidentally, I rode my '71 Raleigh Int'l to work today w/ its relatively recently fitted V-O fluted fenders. I like how they look on that bike with its champagne finish. However, on my Grand Sports and its transition from crappy winter fenders and studded tires to decent fenders and 32mm Paselas, I'm thinking about white Bluemels, largely inspired by yours, Matt!

Neal