I have been a subscriber to Bicycle Quarterly since the second issue came out. I believe that Jan Heine make a good case that newest is not always best for the non-pro rider that most of us are. While he praises items from the heyday of cycling, stressing durability, comfort and funcionality over lightness, he make an interesting case for the continued use of these items or their modern day subsitutes. One only has to look at the popularity of stores like Rivendell and Velo Orange among the more dedicated cyclists that are trying to use their cars less to see that the trend is growing. Yes I do have a bike with 25mm tires, but I certainly ride the one with the 35mm tires much more as it is more comfortable (tried what BQ said and it works). Also ride the steel bikes with their relaxed geometry more than the aluminum ones (BQ and Rivendell tip again). All I can say is to read BQ and the somewhat random production but also interesting Rivendell magazine and judge for yourself. Only you can decide what is best for you!