if it only takes an hour to get a sore butt, you probably need some toughness or else you have a really strange butt. I've found that it takes 80 miles of continuous riding before I can really judge a saddle. I like the fizik Aliante. It might be a little too wide for me, but I can live with that.

For some reason I didn't notice you had tried the Aliante. Too bad it didn't work.