My partner currently has a Surly Crosscheck and has leather handlebar tape on the handlebars. Although durable, the problem is the leather is so thin and lacks cushion that when he rides long distances, his hands get extremely sore and tired. Using gel gloves helps but only provides relief for so long. He's going to be doing a bike tour and wants to replace the handlebar tape prior to his journey. He's looking at two different kinds:

Cinelli Gel/Cork Handlebar tape
http://www.competitivecyclist.com/pr...254.213.0.html

OR

Deda Foam Handlebar tape
http://www.competitivecyclist.com/co...-tape.212.html

Any suggestions, comparisons and/or feedback would be great. Which handlebar tape is likely to last the longest? Which will provide the most comfort for long-distance riding?

Thank you !