Originally Posted by
sambb
fascinating discussion here.... this begs the question ---- is it wrong to go for more of a plush bike like synapse or cervelo RS? In other words, should I consider a CAAD? I am NOT a racer. But, it seems like CAAD sells a lot more at the LBS. Will the comfort/plush bike be boring? How do i know if I will desire a CAAD?
You don't have to be a racer to enjoy a CAAD10 (the current iteration). Having said that, there's a downside to such a bike, as noted by Laminarman. A great bike that doesn't do what you want won't be ridden often, and the main idea (for fun and fitness) is to ride often. On a bike like the RS or the Synapse, you can create a relatively aggressive position if you want, but it's difficult to create a more relaxed position on a bike like the CAAD10.
The CAAD10 sells well because it's probably the best bang-for-buck bike for racers and cyclists who like to go fast, and have the flexibility to fit it. You describe yourself as fit, but even when I was a semi-studly younger guy I had limitations due to flexibility. That's just another consideration.
I'm getting a Synapse Carbon 5 in the next couple of months, and I'm looking forward to it. It's what I'm looking for in a bike in my price range. I'd recommend it, or the aluminum version of it, or the RS. Giant, Specialized, Trek and other brands offer similar bikes which are worth looking at (assuming there are dealers in your area). They're all of good quality.
Oh, and
none of them will be boring.
