I have owned 3 BD bike and I have been pleasantly surprised with the quality of the price. I just sold some clip-less pedals today to a guy that had the BD Fanthom Cross Pro and loves it.
The Windsor Tourist seems like great value. If it was mandated that I only have one bike I would consider selling everything else and buying one of those.
Its been suggested already, but maybe have 2 bikes. One could be a cheap ghetto bike maybe a singlespeed and the other could be something nicer. Singlespeed is another option entirely since its about as reliable as you can get if you can do that.