Originally Posted by
Gene465
Thanks, I want to stay with one of my LBS which one has the Treks the other the Giants. I have three Trek/Fisher MTBs at the house. Wrenching is not an issue as I have a stand and tools. PG if I could get the Defy 1 for that price that you did it would be a no brainer! But my lbs is set at 1300 for the Defy and 1249 on the Trek. Only difference between the two bikes that I could see was the 105 crank on the Defy. Though I am more partial to the Red/black scheme on the Trek. Ride wise both very comparable. I just saw that frame and knew it was the same one as the Defy. Thanks Gene
The Trek and Giant frame geometries are very different. Have you actually ridden both of them. They feel completely different.