Originally Posted by
AdamDZ
Would it make that much difference if the rack was few cm narrower? I really doubt that the extra width of the rack would matter. So far I had no issues riding with my panniers in NYC traffic, and my panniers are usually stuffed and I do have a shortened handlebar. And I like how the rack keeps my panniers away from my disc brakes and wheels. But I don't squeeze that tightly between cars. I know some people do, but then get a backpack or messenger bag IMHO.
The non-disc rack is 6cm narrower which is not insignificant, but I see your point about the width of gaps in traffic which are probably wider than I think, probably way more than the bike's extremities, otherwise I probably wouldn't even try to squeeze through.
I've ordered the Super Tourist DX rack which I'll try on my bike - hopefully the frame won't interfere with the mudguard struts, but if it does, then I'll get the disc version of the same rack and use that.
I'm avoiding a messenger bag or backpack because of the sweaty-back-syndrome.
Thanks for all your feedback and advice.