While the two bikes are similar in many ways, they are two different animals. No1mad and dscheidt are right; you need to test ride these bikes. FWIW I think you're selling yourself short by putting all of your focus on these two bikes. Although both are fine machines, and highly touted on these forums, time spent visiting the local bike shops in your area and test riding all kinds of bikes is the best way to find the right ride for you.