Originally Posted by
Drew Eckhardt
Counter-intuitively, bicycles stand on the lower spokes which see a decrease in tension with minimal changes elsewhere in the wheel.
Barring damage (like shifting the chain into them) spokes fail due to fatigue, with the number of cycles dependent on average stress (where the elbows in non-stress relieved spokes have areas with high average stress because they were never taken past their elastic limit) and magnitude of the variation (which is obviously higher for bigger riders and/or with luggage).
Well, there is a huge thread somewhere in the mechanic forum about that argument which i never got to the bottom of. The upshot seems that the effect is the same either way, excessive stress, fatigue, failure.