The stark and simple design of the leather saddles like the Brooks is initially off putting, so I understand your concern.

I had to get rid of the stock WTB saddle so I used a Forte gel saddle until numbness necessitated I get a better saddle. I selected the Selle Anatomica. It is a Brooks style leather seat but has a cut out down the middle, and I really like it. I'm glad I waited to get the right saddle, but had I known how comfortable these are, I wouldn't have waited. Selle has a reputation of not needing a break in period, but some people say that not every Brooks needs a break in period either.

Some people have been tempted to get the Brooks models that have a spring, but they are a bit bouncy for any faster riding.