After 3000 miles on my stock Cannondale Saddle I think my butt has had enough pain and numbness.

At first I thought it was because of my $15 shorts, but I just got some high quality Castelli stuff and no change.

What saddle is usually the most preferred by most people?

I know Brooks saddles are supposed to be some of the best, but man! Those things are UGLY. My max price is around $60-80 so nothing fancy. Thanks!