So... after riding the 58cm around for a bit and re-measuring myself I'm on the fence again. Without shoes I'm 6'1" 1/2 with about a 33" 1/2 inseam. So with shoes lets just say about 6'2" and 34" inseam. I also have pretty long arms. Fortunately my shop offers a 7 day exchange period, so I'm going back to try out the 63cm.

I could probably fit either with adjustments, but I'm showing at lot of seatpost on the 58cm and it feels a tad cramped. We'll see how the 63cm feels! Ah, indecision...