Originally Posted by
punkncat
Although I find the data in the link to be a bit dubious, it appears they did not do a real "study" but only searched keywords in relation to stretching and muscle injury, and other articles. In these clinical article reviews I am sure there was a lot of information, but it seems to me that in order to prove a hypothesis of this nature there should be a study done with a wide spectrum of volunteers performing various activities with and without stretching. Then the results of the study can be reviewed for it's individual merit, and not just what was found in a keyword search.
This does not mean I don't believe it, and will certainly be looking more into this. I did note that "articles that suggested streching was beneficial included...warm-up"
I would most certainly agree that the people responsible for this article are much more studied than myself, so I would agree with the assessment that in order to effectively stretch there needs to be some manner of warm up first.
Thanks much for the informative posts.
You need to look up what "meta-analysis" means. In that link, you're reading an abstract of their review of the literature, and only included well-designed studies with some kind of control or comparison group. If you want more, read the articles under the "related citations" heading to the right.
Given that, one of the all time best books on stretching is by
Anderson. He recommends warming up.