View Single Post
Old 08-26-11 | 12:08 AM
  #13  
Jimi77
Used & Abused
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 314
Likes: 0

Bikes: GT Avalanche 2.0 + Burley D'lite

Originally Posted by Loose Chain
Some of your numbers do not make sense, you said too high or low and now you say low instead of high**********? If I were to fit you I would have to measure you for myself etc . Not arguing, I am sincerely interested, you ride a 22 inch (56cm) frame that fit or a 21? Hmm, I am 5-11 (and shrinking due to getting older) and I ride a 56cm also. I run my seat at 76cm center of BB to crown of seat give or take a little since some of my bikes have a 170 crank and a few have 175 cranks and one a 172 crank. Plus, of course there is seat setback differences due to frame angle differences and so on. My cycling inseam, PBH is 86cm.

I used to fit bikes some years back. I was fitted by a cycling coach myself, back in 1984, he had been a cycling coach for several pro teams and was doing a fit clinic at a local shop. I was fitted another time by yet another pro level coach, nearly same result. I am not entirely sure how they came to their fit but the first one set my saddle at exactly what 109% rule would predict, the later fitting, he left it alone but did shift my seat and stem length a bit.

The 109% is not new, it goes back a long ways. It is not just opinion, it is based on experimentation and measuring power output over distance and comfort over distance. It has been found that the 109% rule, which is sorta similar to the PBH minus 10cm method, for most cyclist produces the greatest power output over time. Of course, it is also true that in triathlons, they tend to run their saddles higher, same in time trials, but, take a look at a tri/trials bike and figure why that might be.

So, you are 6 feet tall and you are on a 21 inch frame? Interesting. At 6 feet, without knowing your PBH or any measurements, I would probably start with a 58cm frame, 58cm TT.

Good luck.

LC
Rode a 56cm/22" - sold that bike, upper back injury + road bike geometry wasn't mixing.

Bought a 535cm/xl/~21" today (Specialized Crossroad).

We have the same PBH, so what saddle height works for you? Right now I'm at 33" and may move that up a tick.

I'm beginning to think the formula should be PBH, give or take ~10-20%.
Jimi77 is offline  
Reply