Originally Posted by
StephenH
I notice in the article, he keeps saying "If you race or ride race-like", etc, then his opinions don't apply to you. That seems fishy to me. That sounds like a weasel-way of saying "If you really do benefit from clipless pedals, then you must be a racer-guy".
I take your point, but I believe Grant's position on racing is reasonable. He is speaking in generalities. Sure, there are enthusiasts and fit riders who will benefit from and appreciate bike designs and gear intended for racers. But in the main, many recreational riders are better served by design decisions and gear more appropriate to casual riding.
Take seat-to-bar drop as an example. One of the strongest local racers whom I know rides with a seat-to-bar drop that would leave me with back and arm pain and flying over the bars. He is well-served by his choice, but most casual riders are better served by a more comfortable and secure position on the bike. Grant builds his brand image around the "not racing" rider.