Originally Posted by
Richard Cranium
The facts are such that for a given 500 lumen flashlight with a "hot spot" you can and will effectively "blind" someone at 200 yards. But don't be confused.
My point is that "smartly designed" lights and reflectors do not need to be powered up to automotive standards to be safe. And again if you read the original post - the real "need" is in the the ability to swtich from some "blinding throw power" to a civilized, just 30 feet out parking light as needed.
I'm already doing all these things, but I have to have a flashlight and a bike light to do it. And two different battery systems as well -hence the need for this thread.
It's all about control folks - but I agree - more power in urban situations is a necessity......
I don't buy the "we need a dimmer light" argument. Most all lights have a beam spread. A flashlight has a beam spread of pretty close to 35 degrees and, especially for LED, the emitter isn't in the best location for the reflector...it's usually behind the focal point. Using a 35 degree cone and a 600 foot length, the cone at that distance is 116 feet in diameter. The light may have a hot spot but, for the most part, the beam is spread out over 107,000 square feet or 1200 sq yards. At 200 yards, there's hardly enough light density with a 500 lumen light to even notice the light much less be blinded by it. The lux (lumens/area) is 0.41 lumens/sq yard. Even if you boosted the light output to 2000 lumens, you'd still have only 1.67 lux. 0.41 lux is comparable to a full moon. The high output light would be comparable to a full moon at the equator. Hardly 'blinding'.
I don't know about you but my lights aren't aimed 200 yards down the road. Even my car lights aren't aimed that far down the road...not even on high beam. I don't go fast enough nor is the light output of a bicycle light enough to justify that kind of aiming. Generally speaking, my lights are aimed around 2 to 3 car lengths (roughly 30 feet) ahead of me which is far enough for me to see obstacles at normal riding speed. I'd rather have a lot of light aimed down at the ground where it's useful than a little light aimed very far down the road where it's wasted.