I want to use Lizard Skins, but I have ethical concerns with them skinning that many lizards.

More seriously, some people are picky about tape, some aren't, only way to find out which type you like is to try some out. I don't know how much good other people's advice is gonna do you. Like hairnet said, it's a personal thing.

That being said, if you're also learning how to wrap handlebars, maybe buy a couple packs of the cheap cork stuff so you won't be scared to mess up.