I think that the PSA testing should continue. The real kicker is in their report "Two out of every five men whose prostate cancer is detected through a PSA test, one study found, have a slow-growing cancer that would never have posed any threat to their lives" That means that 3/5 men do have cancer that can be a threat to their lives. I have been there and done that. My PSA jumped from 1.3 to 4 in one year. I had a second PSA test after a bout of antibiotics followed by a biopsy. Talk a bout a kick below the belt when the doctor says you have cancer. I went home and did a ton of research, found the best surgeon in my medical plan and then I had surgery and I am now a member of the "Zero Club" (PSA of less then 0.04) for the past two years. While I am sure that I would still be alive today without the PSA test I would probably not be paying taxes any longer after about 8 more years (based on the post op exam of my prostrate). Based on the average life expectancy of about 84 for a US male I can see in not recommending the PSA test in men over 75. Those biopsies hurt and having blood coming out there is not a pleasant sight. Those are my thoughts and experiences.