One of the differences amongst the opinions stated here is that those of us who used the PSA test and found cancer will continue to use the test. Those who may not be inclined to use PSA testing for themselves seem to be without actual personal experience with cancer diagnosis. I agree that all of our reported experiences of cancer diagnosis after PSA testing is not as academic/controlled as the referenced study may have been, but I will continue to take PSA tests often. It is much the same when a bureaucrat who has no actual personal experience with the process makes the decision for us. Good luck, whatever choice you make.