One bike? Ogre.
Take my opinion with a grain of salt. 1) I'm a surly fan (I have an LHT and a Big Dummy) 2) I don't (yet) own a typical road bike.
A multi-purpose bike is the ticket.
If you're willing to vary from those you listed:
Surly Crosscheck
Surly LHT
Salsa Vaya
etc...