After lot's of research and dreaming of the perfect bike it's time to actually buy a bike. The budget has shrunk from the dream of an Jamis Aurora Elite to something much more affordable. So herare the choices. Two different bikes with the same primary purpose but offering different options for other riding. They'll mainly be used on a 11 mile RT commute. Both fit.

http://www.khsbicycles.com/12_vitamin_b_m_12.htm
Pretty much a solid bike for it's purpose. Not much versatillity.


http://www.gtbicycles.com/2012/bikes...-avalanche-4-0
Will get the job done. Can be used for light off road riding. Front shock will protect damaged right shoulder. Can be upgraded to discs if needed.

Any thoughts? I'm hoping to ride through the Winter. There are some local spots to go off road nearby that I can ride to. I have a nice road bike. My old commuter was in an accident repairs and upgrading it will cost more than either of these bikes.

Thanks.