I'd look at a 58cm (582mm ETTL). And, if the LBS has a 61cm (600mm ETTL), I'd look at that, too. The 61cm is 18mm longer in the toptube, but, picks up 20mm in headtube length. Both sizes use the same stem. Your LBS should be able to order in a 61cm with no obligation to purchase. Without knowing your body dimensions/proportions, it's hard to be accurate with this.

I'm 5'10" (shorter torso/longer legged) and was fitted to a 58cm Specialized. But, with my own thoughts on fitment, I later bought a 54cm and feel much better. I went from struggling with various pains on the 58cm to easy 100+ mile days on a 54cm. YMMV.