I feel that you can't go wrong with a Bianchi, but I'm biased.....I'm sure the Advantage would meet most of your immediate needs, but I think you might outgrow it quickly if you want to go on group rides longer than say 10-15 miles. For an extra $70, you could step up to the Boardwalk, which will be lighter and have a more road-like stance. You'd also be getting rid of the suspension seatpost - I know it sounds great now, but believe me, you won't need it. If you go with a Bianchi, remember to get the celeste. Good luck on your purchase. One of the bikes that you test ride will sing to you - that's the one to get. Let us know what you decide and happy riding.