Originally Posted by
Alan Edwards
Did you convert the 110 so you could go compact or just to get some rings? ... Looking at the pictures you need to add the counterset so the bolts sit flush. Have you used them yet? ... Wondering how this would hold up in the long term.
It's a little from column "A", a little from column "B"; I started looking for some compact 116BCD rings that were suitably inexpensive. Being unable to find any, I realized that I already owned a set of 110 BCD rings in exactly the sizes I wanted. Since they were nice enough to use and rough enough to risk on a foolish venture, the idea was born!
I considered whether or not to add the countersinking at the edge of the newly-enlarged holes. I don't feel like the large chainring would have enough meat left, but I might countersink the holes on the back of the small chainring (especially if they give me any clearance issues back there).
I haven't gotten a chance to mount them up and use them yet, but I'm looking forward to it. I think they will probably hold up just fine due to friction taking a portion of the load that would otherwise be borne by shear strength of the bolts and bolt-holes (bolt-ovals?). I'll try 'em out on the trainer well before spring comes!
If I had a nice drill press at my disposal, I think the Origin-8 110/130 "universal" chainring would be a great candidate for a slightly more sophisticated version of this procedure. They've got tons of extra aluminum in the region where one would be cutting and drilling.