Originally Posted by
cyccommute
Discs aren't impervious to damage. If anything they are slightly more delicate than rims. A disc requires hyper-straight rotors to continue working. Even a slight bend to the rotor will cause rubbing at the very least. Stuff happens out in the real world that could easily result in hub mounted discs being completely unworkable.
As usual, I think you're over-stating the fragility of disc brakes. In my experience, it's difficult to bend a 160mm brake disc to the point where it becomes unusable without also causing serious damage to the surrounding components (ex: wheel, fork, frame,
rider). The best I've been able to do in my numerous mountain bike crashes, was bend the brake rotor to the point where it rubbed the pads a bit... just like an out-of-true wheel tends to rub against rim brake pads. In both cases, braking performance suffers. Luckily, most bikes have
two brakes.