Thanks for the links 2ndGen...so either something's very wrong or I'm crazy (btw I used digital calipers AND a measuring tape to confirm). I've sent an email to my LBS and will call 'em tomorrow. I appreciate your help!

If anyone with a CAAD10 is able to measure, I'd still be interested for a confirmation if you've got 130mm..

edit: LBS emailed back, saying it sounds weird and they want to take a look. damnit...my backup bike is in the shop getting serviced already, so I've apparently gone from 2 to 0 working bikes. Don't feel safe using the CAAD10 until LBS has looked at it..