Hello all, I am a newbie and I have zero knowledge about bikes.

I am looking to buy something that I can commute around New York City streets with. And, although not a huge priority, something that is versatile so I can humor the notion of riding off-road. I want something relatively comfortable (seems like it would be more comfy to sit a bit upright) and I am not exactly looking to be the fastest guy on the street either. I just want something simple and entry-level, but also don't want to end up with complete crap.

Also, I don't want anything too flashy that screams out "steal me!" or "rob all my parts!"

My price range is around $500.

I would like to buy a complete. I don't really have the time and energy to do all the research into putting together components for a custom bike. I also don't know anything. Chances are I wouldn't be able to differentiate a good ride from a bad ride.

A buddy of mine, suggested that I look into getting a single speed/fixed gear road bike.

I was thinking maybe an inexpensive entry-level hybrid.

I visited some of the local bike shops yesterday. Here's some of the bikes they suggested:

Fat Cycles (couldn't find a website for this brand; actually couldn't find any information at all on this brand) for $420

Pure Fix for $420

Redline 925 (they didn't have it at the store, but suggested I look into it)

KHS Urban Soul for $400

Felt Brougham for $550

I would also like to add that I think I would be more comfortable riding a free wheel. According to the employees that I talked to, all/most of the models I listed are flip-flop (they can be converted to free wheel or fixed gear).

Right now, I am leaning towards the Felt Brougham, or possibly the KHS Urban Soul. But I would like to hear some input and suggestions.