Originally Posted by
gyozadude
I would argue that the cost of a square taper JIS BB has never been cheaper. I can buy today, for $18, a Shimano UN55 which is like the UN54 only with metal cups on both sides and not plastic on one. Sealed cartridge bearings. Pretty darn smooth, and square taper. I can also buy a Vuelta BB in square JIS taper in a variety of widths. Sealed cartridge bearings, steel cups. $14. And I just bought a new Vuelta crank, compact crank set, 50-34 for just $30 and it's square taper. So it's not getting that expensive. It's not super high end, but it works great and it's compatible with Shimano. I picked up an SR cheap XCT v2 crank for around the same price, $30 and it supports a square taper.
No argument here- but there are cases, and if weight is no object I'll choose square taper any day. It's really economical. But in the low weight class square taper BBs and cranks are expensive- more than OB bearing crank.