Between my wife and I we have Arkel T42, Arkel X45, Arkel EXR38, Sunset Camping (cheapo no-name from the 80's) with Arkel clips retro-fitted, and the Arkel big handlebar bag.

I'd recommend Arkel.

I'm sure most or all of the top-end bags are great. I like the durability of these bags, their looks and that they have compartments where I want them.

I also like to support a Canadian company.

B