Hey all - some really great looking bikes in this thread! I'm looking to buy a CAAD 10 but have a bit of a sizing dilemma. I'm 6ft 2 inches/188-189cm and have tested a 60cm CAAD10 and a 58cm CAAD8, the CAAD 8 felt comfier so I'm leaning towards ordering a 58cm CAAD 10.

However, there was quite a lot of seatpost showing, quite a few spacers under the stem and I know the CAAD 8 has a slightly taller headtube than the CAAD 10. Would the 58cm or 60cm CAAD 10 be the wiser choice/more flexible in terms of 'fine tuning' position wise? I've attached pictures of the bikes as tested

Thank you very much for your time!