Could it be that after having my saddle too high for a while I am just used to pointing my toes more than I should? Or will it feel more "normal" after a week or so? I moved it down 2.5cm.
Going from a position you're used to to a new one, it takes time to re-acclimate yourself. If you were to get fitted, the guy/gal doing the fitting would emphasize that you need to keep it as is after the fitting and not change it for a couple of weeks. Even when going from wrong to right, right will feel weird until you get used to it.